Potential overtreatment by paramedic students: A study from three South African higher education institutions


paramedic student
clinical learning

How to Cite

Makkink AW, Barnard E. Potential overtreatment by paramedic students: A study from three South African higher education institutions . Australasian Journal of Paramedicine [Internet]. 2022Jun.15 [cited 2022Jun.26];19. Available from: https://ajp.paramedics.org/index.php/ajp/article/view/977


Introduction: Healthcare students are often required to perform predetermined numbers of clinical skills to prove competence. The pressures of meeting predetermined clinical skill numbers may result in students overtreating patients. Overtreatment is not without consequence to the patient. This study aimed to investigate perceptions related to possible overtreatment of patients by emergency medical care students in three South African higher education institutions (HEIs).

Methods: This cross-sectional study used a purpose-designed, anonymous online questionnaire to collect data on possible patient overtreatment from emergency medical care student participants at three South African HEIs.

Results: Of the participants, 45 self-reported reasonably low incidences of overtreatment of patients. The prescribed skill requirements were deemed appropriate as were practical shift numbers, but there was concern about achieving prescribed skill numbers. Participants generally considered risk versus benefit and clinical mentors generally agreed with student decisions without permitting overtreatment practices. Intravenous (IV) cannulation, oxygen administration and spinal immobilisation were the most common forms of overtreatment with advanced airway management and IV cannulation the most difficult to achieve. Lack of appropriately qualified practitioners and low patient numbers were the most common barriers to achieving required skill numbers.

Conclusion: There was concern among participants about not reaching prerequisite skill numbers. Self-reported overtreatment of patients by participants was uncommon. The list of self-reported procedures most often forming part of overtreatment seemed to contradict this. The most common forms of overtreatment were clinical procedures that posed potential risk to the patient. There is a need to further explore overtreatment within healthcare student populations.



Crowe RP, Levine R, Rodriguez S, Larrimore AD, Pirrallo RG. Public perception of emergency medical services in the United States. Prehosp Disaster Med 2016;31:S112–7.

O’Meara P, Williams B, Dicker B, Hickson H. Paramedicine clinical placement duration and quality variance: international benchmarking study. Bendigo, VIC: La Trobe University; 2016. Technical report.

South African Qualifications Authority [Internet]. Pretoria, South Africa: SAQA; n. d. Available from: https://www.saqa.org.za/.

Health Professions Council of South Africa: Professional Board of Emergency Care. Guidelines for the completion of the portfolio for institutions intending to offer the emergency care assistant (ECA), emergency care technician (ECT) and emergency care practitioner (ECP) programmes. Professional Board for Emergency Care Accredited Education and Training Providers 2021:1–4. https://www.hpcsa.co.za/Uploads/EMB/Accreditation/FORM_332_ACCREDITATION_GUIDELINES_FINAL_REVISED_JUNE_2021.pdf

South African Qualifications Authority. Bachelor degree: emergency medical care. SAQA QUAL ID 63129 2018:1–8. Available from: http://allqs.saqa.org.za/showQualification.php?id=63129.

Hadler NM. Medical overtreatment: friend or foe? Gerontology 2018;64:222–8.

Lyu H, Xu T, Brotman D, Mayer-Blackwell B, Cooper M, Daniel M, et al. Overtreatment in the United States. PLoS One 2017;12. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0181970.

Vincent-Lambert C, Van Nugteren B. Student compliance with indications for intravenous cannulation during clinical learning. Afr J Health Prof Educ 2015;7:158–60.

Vincent-Lambert C, Jackson RK. Paramedics’ experiences of financial medicine practices in the pre-hospital environment. A pilot study. Health SA Gesondheid 2016;21:103–9.

Gledstone-Brown L, McHugh D. Idle ‘just-in-case’ peripheral intravenous cannulas in the emergency department: is something wrong? Emerg Med Australas 2018;30:309–26.

Hensher M, Tisdell J, Zimitat C. ‘Too much medicine’: insights and explanations from economic theory and research. Soc Sci Med 2017;176:77–84.

Lawrence D, Lauro A. Complications from IV therapy: results from field-started and emergency department-started IVs compared. Ann Emerg Med 1998;17:314–7.

Mermel LA. Short-term peripheral venous catheter-related bloodstream infections: a systematic review. Clin Infect Dis 2017;65:1757–62.

Evison H, Sweeny A, Ranse J, Carrington M, Marsh N, Byrnes J, et al. Idle peripheral intravenous cannulation: an observational cohort study of pre-hospital and emergency department practices. Scand J Trauma Resusc Emerg Med 2021;29. doi: 10.1186/s13049-021-00941-y.

Demetriou C, Ozer BU, Essau CA. Self-report questionnaires. In: Cautin RL, Lilienfeld SO, editors. The encyclopedia of clinical psychology. 1st ed. New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.; 2015. pp. 1–6.

Shapiro SS, Wilk MB. An analysis of variance test for normality (complete samples). Biometrika 1965;52:591–611.

Schober P, Boer C, Schwarte LA. Correlation coefficients: appropriate use and interpretation. Anesth Analg 2018;126:1763–8.

South African Government. National emergency care education and training (NECET) policy. Pretoria, South Africa: National Department of Health; 2017.

Govender K, Grainger L, Naidoo R, MacDonald R. The pending loss of advanced life support paramedics in South Africa. Afr J Emerg Med 2012;2:59–66.

Gausche M, Tadeo RE, Zane MC, Lewis RJ. Out-of-hospital intravenous access: unnecessary procedures and excessive cost. Acad Emerg Med 1998;5:878–82.

Bester BH, Sobuwa S. Utilisation of prehospital intravenous access. S Afr Med J 2014;104:615–8.

Ala A, Shams-Vahdati S, Taghizadieh A, Miri SH, Kazemi N, Hodjati SR, et al. Cervical collar effect on pulmonary volumes in patients with trauma. Eur J Trauma Emerg Surg 2016;42:657–60.

Ham W, Schoonhoven L, Schuurmans MJ, Leenen LPH. Pressure ulcers from spinal immobilization in trauma patients. J Trauma Acute Care Surg 2014;76:1131–41.

Abram S, Bulstrode C. Routine spinal immobilization in trauma patients: what are the advantages and disadvantages? Surgeon 2010;8:218–22.

Bruijns SR, Guly HR, Wallis LA. Effect of spinal immobilization on heart rate, blood pressure and respiratory rate. Prehosp Disaster Med 2013;28:210–4.

Stanton D, Hardcastle T, Muhlbauer D, van Zyl D. Cervical collars and immobilisation: a South African best practice recommendations. Afr J Emerg Med 2017;7:4–8.